In re Jason Jimenez, Serial No. 97551823 (TTAB Nov. 5, 2025) [Precedential]

(1) Holding

The TTAB reversed the Section 2(d) likelihood of confusion refusal, holding that GASPER ROOFING (ROOFING disclaimed) for roofing services is not likely to cause confusion with the registered mark JASPER CONTRACTORS (CONTRACTORS disclaimed) for identical roofing services. The cumulative differences in the marks’ sight, sound, and commercial impression, combined with an elevated degree of purchaser care, outweighed the identical nature of the services and overlapping trade channels.

(2) Procedural History

  • Application & Refusals: Applicant Jason Jimenez filed a Section 1(a) application to register GASPER ROOFING in Class 37, claiming acquired distinctiveness under Section 2(f). The Examining Attorney issued final refusals under Section 2(e)(4) (primarily merely a surname) and Section 2(d) (likelihood of confusion with JASPER CONTRACTORS).
  • Appeal & Remands: Applicant appealed and requested reconsideration, which was denied. Following initial briefing, the Board sua sponte remanded the application to address Applicant’s unexamined Section 2(f) evidence and a disclaimer of “ROOFING”. The Examining Attorney accepted both, obviating the Section 2(e)(4) refusal. After a second remand to clarify Applicant’s individual entity status via Examiner’s Amendment, the appeal resumed solely on the Section 2(d) refusal.

(3) Issues

  1. Evidentiary: Whether hyperlinks to and screenshots of YouTube videos embedded directly into an appeal brief are admissible to augment the record.
  2. Substantive (Section 2(d)): Whether GASPER ROOFING is likely to cause confusion with JASPER CONTRACTORS when used in connection with legally identical Class 37 roofing services.

(4) Rationale and Conclusion

  • Evidentiary Ruling: Sustained the Examining Attorney’s objection. Under Trademark Rule 2.142(d), the record must be complete prior to appeal. Furthermore, due to the transitory nature of websites, providing hyperlinks and screenshots does not properly make video content of record (video files must be timely submitted in accepted formats under 30 MB via TEAS/TMEO during prosecution, or via a formal request for remand with a transcript prior to the main brief deadline).
  • Services & Trade Channels (DuPont Factors 2 & 3): Both registrations cover unrestricted “roofing services” in Class 37. Because the services are legally identical, the Board presumed identical trade channels and classes of consumers, weighing in favor of confusion.
  • Similarity of the Marks (DuPont Factor 1): Weighed heavily against confusion. The Board rejected the Examining Attorney’s reliance on the “no correct pronunciation” rule to equate “Gasper” and “Jasper,” clarifying that the doctrine applies primarily to coined or fanciful terms without recognized meanings. Because “Gasper” is a recognized surname starting with the hard-G strings “Gas-“/”Gasp-” and “jasper” is a recognized dictionary word (a semi-precious stone) pronounced with a soft “J,” they sound distinct. Even if “Jasper” were perceived as a surname, it is a different surname. Coupled with the distinct disclaimed terms (“ROOFING” vs. “CONTRACTORS”), the marks differ in appearance, sound, connotation, and commercial impression.
  • Purchasing Conditions (DuPont Factor 4): Weighed against confusion. Roofing services are inherently expensive, complex, multi-step transactions (involving consultations, financing, and insurance claims) rather than impulse buys, ensuring even the least sophisticated consumer exercises an elevated degree of care.
  • Actual Confusion (DuPont Factors 7 & 8): Deemed neutral, as the Examining Attorney bears no burden to prove actual confusion in an ex parte proceeding.
  • Conclusion: Balancing the DuPont factors, the substantial differences between the marks and heightened consumer care outweighed the identity of the services and trade channels. The Section 2(d) refusal was reversed.

Key Take-away for practitioners

A commonsense pronunciation may override assumptions based on phonetic equivalents, especially when neither is a coined term.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *