Tag: ttab

  • In re Jason Jimenez, Serial No. 97551823 (TTAB Nov. 5, 2025) [Precedential]

    (1) Holding

    The TTAB reversed the Section 2(d) likelihood of confusion refusal, holding that GASPER ROOFING (ROOFING disclaimed) for roofing services is not likely to cause confusion with the registered mark JASPER CONTRACTORS (CONTRACTORS disclaimed) for identical roofing services. The cumulative differences in the marks’ sight, sound, and commercial impression, combined with an elevated degree of purchaser care, outweighed the identical nature of the services and overlapping trade channels.

    (2) Procedural History

    • Application & Refusals: Applicant Jason Jimenez filed a Section 1(a) application to register GASPER ROOFING in Class 37, claiming acquired distinctiveness under Section 2(f). The Examining Attorney issued final refusals under Section 2(e)(4) (primarily merely a surname) and Section 2(d) (likelihood of confusion with JASPER CONTRACTORS).
    • Appeal & Remands: Applicant appealed and requested reconsideration, which was denied. Following initial briefing, the Board sua sponte remanded the application to address Applicant’s unexamined Section 2(f) evidence and a disclaimer of “ROOFING”. The Examining Attorney accepted both, obviating the Section 2(e)(4) refusal. After a second remand to clarify Applicant’s individual entity status via Examiner’s Amendment, the appeal resumed solely on the Section 2(d) refusal.

    (3) Issues

    1. Evidentiary: Whether hyperlinks to and screenshots of YouTube videos embedded directly into an appeal brief are admissible to augment the record.
    2. Substantive (Section 2(d)): Whether GASPER ROOFING is likely to cause confusion with JASPER CONTRACTORS when used in connection with legally identical Class 37 roofing services.

    (4) Rationale and Conclusion

    • Evidentiary Ruling: Sustained the Examining Attorney’s objection. Under Trademark Rule 2.142(d), the record must be complete prior to appeal. Furthermore, due to the transitory nature of websites, providing hyperlinks and screenshots does not properly make video content of record (video files must be timely submitted in accepted formats under 30 MB via TEAS/TMEO during prosecution, or via a formal request for remand with a transcript prior to the main brief deadline).
    • Services & Trade Channels (DuPont Factors 2 & 3): Both registrations cover unrestricted “roofing services” in Class 37. Because the services are legally identical, the Board presumed identical trade channels and classes of consumers, weighing in favor of confusion.
    • Similarity of the Marks (DuPont Factor 1): Weighed heavily against confusion. The Board rejected the Examining Attorney’s reliance on the “no correct pronunciation” rule to equate “Gasper” and “Jasper,” clarifying that the doctrine applies primarily to coined or fanciful terms without recognized meanings. Because “Gasper” is a recognized surname starting with the hard-G strings “Gas-“/”Gasp-” and “jasper” is a recognized dictionary word (a semi-precious stone) pronounced with a soft “J,” they sound distinct. Even if “Jasper” were perceived as a surname, it is a different surname. Coupled with the distinct disclaimed terms (“ROOFING” vs. “CONTRACTORS”), the marks differ in appearance, sound, connotation, and commercial impression.
    • Purchasing Conditions (DuPont Factor 4): Weighed against confusion. Roofing services are inherently expensive, complex, multi-step transactions (involving consultations, financing, and insurance claims) rather than impulse buys, ensuring even the least sophisticated consumer exercises an elevated degree of care.
    • Actual Confusion (DuPont Factors 7 & 8): Deemed neutral, as the Examining Attorney bears no burden to prove actual confusion in an ex parte proceeding.
    • Conclusion: Balancing the DuPont factors, the substantial differences between the marks and heightened consumer care outweighed the identity of the services and trade channels. The Section 2(d) refusal was reversed.

    Key Take-away for practitioners

    A commonsense pronunciation may override assumptions based on phonetic equivalents, especially when neither is a coined term.

  • Proximo Spirits, Inc. v. West Road Spirits LLC

    Non-precedential opinion of TTAB for proceeding No. 92080766 in 2025

    A copy of the opinion (downloadable at https://ttab-reading-room.uspto.gov) should be appended to the motion or brief. TBMP §101.03(a)(2).

    (1) Holding The Board denied the Petition to Cancel the registration for the mark SEXTO.

    (2) Procedural History The Petitioner, Proximo Spirits, Inc., sought to cancel the registration for the standard character mark SEXTO for “alcoholic beverages, except beer; alcoholic beverages, namely, distilled agave liquor” in International Class 33.

    The Petitioner’s claim was based on its own registered mark, THE SEXTON (in standard characters), for “whiskey” in International Class 33.

    (4) Issues The central issue was whether there was a likelihood of confusion between Petitioner’s mark THE SEXTON and Respondent’s mark SEXTO, as used on their respective alcoholic beverages.

    (5) Rationales The TTAB denied the petition to cancel based on

    • Goods, Channels of Trade, and Consumers: The Board found the goods to be legally identical because the identification “alcoholic beverages, except beer” includes whiskey. The Board also found that distilled agave liquor and whiskey are closely related, as evidenced by third-party registrations and distillery websites offering both under the same marks. Because the goods are identical or closely related, the Board presumed they are sold in the same trade channels and offered to the same classes of consumers. These factors weighed heavily in favor of a likelihood of confusion.
    • Strength of Petitioner’s Mark: The Board found Petitioner’s mark, THE SEXTON, to be both conceptually and commercially strong. The term “sexton” is arbitrary in connection with whiskey, giving it conceptual strength. The evidence also showed commercial strength through significant sales, promotional expenditures, industry awards, and a co-branding partnership with the television show The Walking Dead. This factor weighed in favor of a likelihood of confusion.
    • Dissimilarity of the Marks: The Board concluded that the marks are dissimilar in their overall commercial impression, particularly in their connotation and meaning.
      • Connotation and Meaning: Petitioner’s mark, THE SEXTON, has a specific meaning in English, referring to a church officer or grave digger. This connotation is reinforced by its promotional activities and the word “THE,” which suggests a specific individual. Respondent’s mark, SEXTO, has no understood meaning in English, and in Spanish, it means “sixth”.
      • Appearance: Although SEXTO is only one letter away from SEXTON, the omission of the “N” is significant because consumers are unlikely to perceive it as a misspelling of SEXTON.
      • Sound: The Board found it unlikely that the marks would be pronounced in a similar way.
    • Dissimilarity outweighed other factors: The Board held that the dissimilarity of the marks outweighed the similarities of the goods, trade channels, and the strength of Petitioner’s mark. The differences were “significant” and “substantial,” justifying a conclusion that confusion is unlikely. The Petition to Cancel was therefore denied.
  • In re Ghostwritten LLC

    Non-precedential opinion of TTAB for proceeding No. 98199104 in 2025

    A copy of the opinion (downloadable at https://ttab-reading-room-aws.uspto.gov/cms/rest/legal-proceeding/97344289/decision/EXA_10.pdf) should be appended to the motion or brief. TBMP §101.03(a)(2).

    (1) Holding

    The Board reversed the refusal to register the mark GHOSTWRITTEN INC. because it was not merely descriptive for the Applicant’s services.

    (2) Mark

    The Applicant, Ghostwritten LLC, sought registration on the Principal Register of the standard-character mark GHOSTWRITTEN INC. for numerous services in International Class 41, some of which could be ghostwritten:

    • Educational and entertainment programs accessible via audio, web-based applications, and computer networks (covering daily life, comedy, pop culture, current events, memes, internet videos, and music).
    • Providing websites featuring blogs, non-downloadable podcasts, and videos in various fields like daily life, entertainment, social issues, music, movies, and celebrity news.
    • Providing information in the fields of entertainment and current events.
    • Digital video, audio, and multimedia publishing services, including e-books and electronic publications.
    • Live musical performances, music production, and music publishing services.
    • Entertainment services in the nature of web series and webcasts.
    • Online databases featuring music.
    • Conducting art exhibitions (including NFT art and virtual exhibitions), custom art drawing/sketching, and providing virtual museum services.
    • Film production and multimedia publishing of various media.
    • Providing online non-downloadable virtual clothing, headwear, footwear, eyewear, fashion bags, games, toys, CDs, and DVDs for use in virtual environments for entertainment purposes.

    (3) Procedural History

    The Examining Attorney refused registration on two grounds:

    • Likelihood of Confusion: With four registered marks: GHOSTWRITER (Class 9 – video/DVDs, TV programs), GHOSTWRYTER (Class 41 – music artist/production/live performances), GHOSTWRITER (Class 9 – audio/video recordings, downloadable publications/content), and GHOSTWRITER (Class 16 – printed materials, Class 41 – TV programs, multimedia programs, online information). This ground was withdrawn in the final office action.
    • Mere Descriptiveness: Arguing that GHOSTWRITTEN INC. is merely descriptive of the services because the Applicant provides services related to creative content that could be produced for another who is the presumed or credited creator. The Examining Attorney provided dictionary definitions for “ghostwritten” and Internet evidence showing its common use in creative industries. In the final action, additional evidence was attached to illustrate that blog posts, website content, e-books, and written information are commonly ghostwritten.

    (4) Issues

    Whether the Examining Attorney carried her burden of proving that GHOSTWRITTEN INC. immediately conveys knowledge about a significant feature of Applicant’s services, thereby being merely descriptive under Section 2(e)(1) of the Trademark Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1052(e)(1).

    (5) Rationales

    The TTAB reversed the refusal based on the following rationales:

    • Vagueness and Amorphousness: The Board found the term GHOSTWRITTEN INC. to be “too amorphous, nebulous and vague” for consumers to immediately understand it as describing a significant feature of the Applicant’s recited services. The leap between the mark and the services’ attributes is not “almost instantaneous”.
    • Lack of Prevalance in Public Perception: The Examining Attorney’s evidence did not demonstrate that the consuming public would instantaneously perceive GHOSTWRITTEN INC. as describing a key attribute of Applicant’s specific services.
    • Applicant’s Intent to be Confirmed by Statement of Use: Applicant explicitly stated that “none of the services listed in the identification of services are intended to be created for another who is the presumed or credited creator or author”.
    • Third-Party Registrations: The Board noted that four similar “GHOSTWRITER” or “GHOSTWRYTER” marks were registered without overcoming Section 2(e)(1) refusals, even though they covered creative works. This indicated that the Office had taken a different position in the past, supporting the idea that the public does not immediately understand “GHOSTWRITTEN” as descriptive of such services.
    • Suggestive, Not Merely Descriptive: The Board concluded that the mark is, “at worst, ‘suggestive of the services in connection with which it is used’”. Given the difficulty in drawing the line between descriptive and suggestive marks, any doubt was resolved in favor of the Applicant, as the Examining Attorney failed to meet the burden of establishing mere descriptiveness.
  • In re EquipKeyCo, LLC

    Non-precedential opinion of TTAB for proceeding No. 97344289 in 2025

    A copy of the opinion (downloadable at https://ttab-reading-room-aws.uspto.gov/cms/rest/legal-proceeding/97344289/decision/EXA_10.pdf) should be appended to the motion or brief. TBMP §101.03(a)(2).

    Holding

    The board affirmed the disclaimer requirement and preemptively reversed the likelihood of confusion.

    Mark

    EquipKeyCo, LLC (“Applicant”) sought to register for “pre-fabricated metal ignition keys for starting heavy equipment, namely construction and agricultural equipment” in International Class 6.

    Procedural history

    Examiner required a disclaimer of the wording “EQUIP KEY CO” within the mark, arguing that it is merely descriptive of the Applicant’s goods because “EQUIP” is a recognized abbreviation for “equipment”, “KEY” directly refers to the goods (keys), and “CO” is a common abbreviation for “company”.

    Examiner also refused the registration based on the likelihood of confusion because the applied-for mark’s wording, which is a dominant feature, consists of only the entire wording of the cited mark plus a descriptive wording.

    Issues

    1. Isa unitary mark with a nondescript meaning?
    2. Is likely to be confused with for “metal, brass and aluminum key blanks; metal and aluminum key chains; metal and brass locks, lock cylinders, pad locks and door locks” in Class 6?

    Rationales

    1. Finding the wording Equip Key Co is descriptive, the board noted that the composite mark did not create a unitary mark with a non-descriptive meaning because of the capitalization and coloring. The design elements were deemed irrelevant to the descriptiveness of the wording itself.
    2. The Board found similarity in goods and shared channels, and it doubted the equipment purchasers, however sophisticated, would exercise the same degree of care for small, inexpensive items like keys. Nevertheless, the board found that the words Key and Co were conceptually weak and highly suggestive in connection with keys and key-related goods so as to the difference in design portions was sufficient to avoid confusion. See In re Bed & Breakfast Registry, 791 F.2d 157, 159 (Fed. Cir. 1986); In re Hartz Hotel Servs., Inc., 102 USPQ2d 1150, 1154 (TTAB 2011).